User4/draft/Millions of children are killed or injured every year in bicycle accidents: Difference between revisions

From BoyWiki
(almost done)
No edit summary
Line 3: Line 3:
:"My god! We have to ''do'' something about this! Millions! Killed! Injured!" some concerned parents, [[child savers]], and politicians looking to further their careers may cry out. "We need laws to protect children from bicycle accidents!"
:"My god! We have to ''do'' something about this! Millions! Killed! Injured!" some concerned parents, [[child savers]], and politicians looking to further their careers may cry out. "We need laws to protect children from bicycle accidents!"


This is an example of deceiving people while still telling the truth. It is a kind of [[framing]]--the average person sees only "Millions/Children/Killed/Injured" and doesn't stop to think exactly ''how many'' children are killed, and ''how many'' children are injured. And they don't ask, "What ''percentage'' of children who ride bicycles die from doing so?" "What ''percentage'' of children are ''injured'' riding bicycles?" "What ''percentage'' of children ''ride bicycles and suffer absolutely no injuries at all, and neither do they die''"?
This is an example of deceiving people while still telling the truth. It is a kind of [[Framing (dictionary)|framing]]--the average person sees only "Millions/Children/Killed/Injured" and doesn't stop to think exactly ''how many'' children are killed, and ''how many'' children are injured. And they don't ask, "What ''percentage'' of children who ride bicycles die from doing so?" "What ''percentage'' of children are ''injured'' riding bicycles?" "What ''percentage'' of children ''ride bicycles and suffer absolutely no injuries at all, and neither do they die''"?


In fact, the number of children who ''die'' is very very small. I have not checked yet, but it is probably in the range of dozens, not hundreds. As a ''percentage'' of all children who ride bicycles, it is so small that it is virtually inconsequential.
In fact, the number of children who ''die'' is very very small. I have not checked yet, but it is probably in the range of dozens, not hundreds. As a ''percentage'' of all children who ride bicycles, it is so small that it is virtually inconsequential.
Line 11: Line 11:
How about the number of children who are ''injured'' in bicycle accidents? The fact is, ''millions of children '''are''' injured every year in bicycle accidents!''
How about the number of children who are ''injured'' in bicycle accidents? The fact is, ''millions of children '''are''' injured every year in bicycle accidents!''


:"My god! We have to ''do'' something about this! Millions! Injured!" some may cry out. "We need laws to protect children from bicycle accidents!"
:"My god! We have to ''do'' something about this! Millions! Injured!" some concerned parents, [[child savers]], and politicians looking to further their careers may cry out. "We need laws to protect children from bicycle accidents!"


:(Begin obligatory "politically correct" addendum: "But every child injured in a bicycle accident is a great tragedy!" End obligatory "politically correct" addendum.)
:(Begin obligatory "politically correct" addendum: "But every child injured in a bicycle accident is a great tragedy!" End obligatory "politically correct" addendum.)
Line 21: Line 21:
:(Begin obligatory "politically correct" addendum: "But every serious injury to a child's is a horrible tragedy!" End obligatory "politically correct" addendum.)
:(Begin obligatory "politically correct" addendum: "But every serious injury to a child's is a horrible tragedy!" End obligatory "politically correct" addendum.)


What ''percentage'' of children injured in bicycle accidents suffer from ''minor'' injuries, like skinned knees? I am sure (but, no, I have not checked yet) that the vast majority of injuries are minor ones, requiring no medical treatment other than a little disinfectant and a Band-Aid.
What ''percentage'' of children injured in bicycle accidents suffer from ''minor'' injuries, like skinned knees? I am sure (but, no, I have not recently checked) that the vast majority of injuries are minor ones, requiring no medical treatment other than a little disinfectant and a Band-Aid.


:"My god! We have to ''do'' something about this! Millions! Injured! Think of the psychological trauma those innocent children must suffer!" some concerned parents, child savers, and politicians looking to further their careers may cry out. "We need laws to protect children from bicycle accidents!"
:"My god! We have to ''do'' something about this! Millions! Injured! Think of the psychological trauma those innocent children must suffer!" some concerned parents, child savers, and politicians looking to further their careers may cry out. "We need laws to protect children from bicycle accidents!"


Right. Let's ban children from riding bicycles. ''The harms to children are clear!''
Right. Let's ban children from riding bicycles. ''The harms to children are clear!''
:(Begin obligatory "politically correct" addendum: "Of course I want to protect children from harm!" End obligatory "politically correct" addendum.)


Uh, huh. Children should not have the right to ride bicycles. Children should have no right to independent transportation. They should have no right to the joy, the feeling of freedom, and the simple pleasures that riding bicycles gives them. There is no necessity for children to ride bicycles--they can refrain from riding bicycles until they reach the age of legal majority. Children cannot make an "informed decision" about riding bicycles. They are not yet reached cognitive maturity. If an adult offers to buy a child a bicycle for his/her birthday, the child cannot give "[[informed consent]]". And "[[simple consent]]" can never be sufficient.
Uh, huh. Children should not have the right to ride bicycles. Children should have no right to independent transportation. They should have no right to the joy, the feeling of freedom, and the simple pleasures that riding bicycles gives them. There is no necessity for children to ride bicycles--they can refrain from riding bicycles until they reach the age of legal majority. Children cannot make an "informed decision" about riding bicycles. They are not yet reached cognitive maturity. If an adult offers to buy a child a bicycle for his/her birthday, the child cannot give "[[informed consent]]". And "[[simple consent]]" can never be sufficient.

Revision as of 20:33, 11 May 2016

This is a fact. You can check the government figures, and it is absolutely true! (I looked it up once, but I didn't keep a record of it.) Millions of children are killed or injured every year in bicycle accidents. It's a fact.

"My god! We have to do something about this! Millions! Killed! Injured!" some concerned parents, child savers, and politicians looking to further their careers may cry out. "We need laws to protect children from bicycle accidents!"

This is an example of deceiving people while still telling the truth. It is a kind of framing--the average person sees only "Millions/Children/Killed/Injured" and doesn't stop to think exactly how many children are killed, and how many children are injured. And they don't ask, "What percentage of children who ride bicycles die from doing so?" "What percentage of children are injured riding bicycles?" "What percentage of children ride bicycles and suffer absolutely no injuries at all, and neither do they die"?

In fact, the number of children who die is very very small. I have not checked yet, but it is probably in the range of dozens, not hundreds. As a percentage of all children who ride bicycles, it is so small that it is virtually inconsequential.

(Begin obligatory "politically correct" addendum: "But every loss of a child's life is a horrible tragedy!" End obligatory "politically correct" addendum.)

How about the number of children who are injured in bicycle accidents? The fact is, millions of children are injured every year in bicycle accidents!

"My god! We have to do something about this! Millions! Injured!" some concerned parents, child savers, and politicians looking to further their careers may cry out. "We need laws to protect children from bicycle accidents!"
(Begin obligatory "politically correct" addendum: "But every child injured in a bicycle accident is a great tragedy!" End obligatory "politically correct" addendum.)

But then you have to ask: what does injured mean? Yes, millions are injured. But what kind of injuries do children receive in bicycle accidents? There are serious injuries, less serious injuries, and minor injuries.

As for serious injuries, I have not checked yet, but it is probably in the range of hundreds, not thousands. As a percentage of all children who ride bicycles, it is so small that it is virtually inconsequential.

(Begin obligatory "politically correct" addendum: "But every serious injury to a child's is a horrible tragedy!" End obligatory "politically correct" addendum.)

What percentage of children injured in bicycle accidents suffer from minor injuries, like skinned knees? I am sure (but, no, I have not recently checked) that the vast majority of injuries are minor ones, requiring no medical treatment other than a little disinfectant and a Band-Aid.

"My god! We have to do something about this! Millions! Injured! Think of the psychological trauma those innocent children must suffer!" some concerned parents, child savers, and politicians looking to further their careers may cry out. "We need laws to protect children from bicycle accidents!"

Right. Let's ban children from riding bicycles. The harms to children are clear!

(Begin obligatory "politically correct" addendum: "Of course I want to protect children from harm!" End obligatory "politically correct" addendum.)

Uh, huh. Children should not have the right to ride bicycles. Children should have no right to independent transportation. They should have no right to the joy, the feeling of freedom, and the simple pleasures that riding bicycles gives them. There is no necessity for children to ride bicycles--they can refrain from riding bicycles until they reach the age of legal majority. Children cannot make an "informed decision" about riding bicycles. They are not yet reached cognitive maturity. If an adult offers to buy a child a bicycle for his/her birthday, the child cannot give "informed consent". And "simple consent" can never be sufficient.

OK--now that that is settled, let's look at another problem. Child sexual abuse.

Millions of children are killed while being sexually abused, are the victims of unwanted sexual assaults, and are sexualized each year by pedophiles!"

"My god! We have to do something about this! Millions! Killed! Sexual assaults! Sexualized!" some concerned parents, child savers, and politicians looking to further their careers may cry out. "We need laws to protect children from sexual abuse!"

Hmm. The intelligent, thinking, and informed reader may want to ask, "Maybe, but what percentages of children..."

But if he does, he will be shouted down by the concerned parents, by the child savers, and by the politicians looking to further their careers.

"We need laws to protect children from sexual abuse!" "And think of the psychological trauma those innocent children must suffer!"

Yes, but...

Hmm... Oh well... So what if millions of families are destroyed, millions of adults are charged (rightly or wrongly) with "sex crimes and millions of children are at risk of being accused of molesting their fellow classmates and then subjected to (unproven and contested) forms of "treatment," for being "sexual offenders"?

After all, it's all about "saving the children," isn't it?